Homeland security involves a variety of activities
that protect life, property and critical infrastructure. Remote sensing
and related geospatial technologies play a vital role in these
activities by detecting, identifying, mapping and monitoring the effects
of natural and man-made hazards and disasters, as well as enhancing
emergency management through time-sensitive damage assessments. Much of
this discussion focuses on remote sensing for assessing vegetation
damage and soil contamination, including artificial radionuclide
contamination, along with damage to urban areas and other human
settlements.
Environmental Damage Assessment
A key component of homeland security lies with securing and maintaining
a healthy, sustainable environment to ensure sufficient agricultural
production and food security. Remote sensing is valuable for
agricultural monitoring and modeling, as well as for assessing climate
change, which may significantly affect food and water supplies.
For example the U.S. Department of Defense recently released a report
examining the link between climate change and U.S. national security.
The report noted the potential for climate change to destabilize the
international geopolitical environment, possibly resulting in future
conflicts and wars based on related food and water shortages. Regardless
of the feasibility of such a scenario, remote sensing can help assess
vegetation stress or damage stemming from a variety of sources.
One agricultural threat to homeland security and
international stability may take the form of Ug99, a virulent strain of
black stem rust fungus (Puccinia graminis). Discovered in Uganda in
1999, the fungus has since spread via airborne spores, though it also
can be transported by travelers. The Puccinia graminis fungus affects
wheat, which is significant because wheat feeds more people than any
other food source. Research into rust fungus-resistant varieties is
being conducted, and remote sensing can be used to detect and monitor
wheat rust.
Another important agricultural threat is drought, which is among the
costliest natural hazards in the United States. Unlike some other
hazards, drought develops slowly; however, it can exert severe
environmental, economic and social consequences, the effects of which
can persist over a long time period. Other types of natural disasters
also can adversely affect vegetation communities, including floods,
hurricanes and severe windstorms.
Many remote sensing studies
have addressed vegetation abundance or health/stress mapping by using
vegetation indices, such as the normalized difference vegetation index,
to estimate relative abundance and photosynthetic activity of green
vegetation. Hyperspectral imaging is particularly useful for such
applications, where hundreds of contiguous bands are available for
information extraction.
Many of the concepts used to assess natural disaster-induced vegetation
damage also apply to man-made scenarios. However, special consideration
is given here to nuclear/radiological event-induced vegetation damage
and soil contamination.
If artificial radio-nuclides are released from a nuclear facility—either
accidentally or deliberately as the result of a terrorist strike—gamma
spectrometric sensors can be used to quickly and broadly map
nuclide-specific contamination. In situ and airborne gamma spectrometric
sensors can be used to survey point releases from nuclear facilities,
monitor radioactive fallout over large regions and detect lost or stolen
radioactive sources.
Mobile or fixed gamma-ray sensors can provide field data. Mobile in situ
gamma spectrometers can be operated on foot or by car to sample at
specific locations as required. Fixed monitoring networks can
continuously measure the gamma dose rate.
One example of a sensor network is the SensorNet Program, which was
designed and developed by Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and
partners. SensorNet began with the concept of mounting wireless sensors
on static and mobile platforms for emergency response. SensorNet
involves developing data-processing and information-delivery methods for
chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear and explosive (CBRNE)
sensors that detect, identify and assess CBRNE threats in real time. If
a CBRNE event is detected, the modeling system will execute a real-time
plume model, predict the impact on populations and recommend actions.
Another distributed sensor network oriented toward
detecting CBRNE threats is the Department of Homeland Security’s
"Cell-All" program, which is currently in the research phase. The idea
is to incorporate chemical, biological and radiological sensors into
cell phones; upon detection of a possible threat, spatio-temporal
information would be transmitted to emergency responders. Although there
may be privacy concerns, such an approach would enable near-ubiquitous
detection capability.
Optical and hyperspectral remotely sensed imagery also provide useful
information for environmental damage assessments associated with
radiological disasters, particularly for civil and scientific users.
Radionuclide contamination-induced vegetation stress can be discerned in
reflectance spectra. In the event of a radiological disaster, such
assessments can be critical for studying human exposure and ecosystem
health, as well as for determining global food security, which was
considered in the wake of the Chernobyl nuclear accident in 1986.
Assessing and monitoring such contamination is also important for
analyzing potential secondary contamination from, for example, fire
events, which can transport contaminants via ash and smoke.
In addition, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) can be flown over areas of
high radiological contamination without exposing personnel to dangerous
radiation levels. Multiple UAVs may be required to serve this function,
particularly in a time-sensitive disaster-response environment.
In short, remotely evaluating vegetation damage in a hazards context is
vital for agricultural production, and it can be used as a proxy
indicator of environmental contamination from natural or man-made
disasters. Widespread drought or fungal or insect infestation could
threaten the ability of the increasing national and global human
population to feed itself. As for contamination, some contaminants may
persist for many years, potentially rendering large tracts of land
unusable for human activity. These phenomena are clear threats to
homeland security.
Urban Damage Assessment
An important dimension of disaster assessment in populated areas
involves estimating the population affected by a given natural or
technological event. In case of a disaster, a first priority is to
assess and limit human injuries and fatalities; a second priority is to
assess structural damage and recovery. Such assessments can be
accomplished—at least in part—through remote sensing. However, a more
accurate method entails the joint use of GIS-based modeling.
A population database is required to estimate the
population affected by a given disaster, and remote sensing can be an
important tool for the task. Various approaches have been followed. For
example, human population has been estimated at the local level by
counting individual dwelling units. However, this approach is costly,
time-consuming and impractical if a regional population base is to be
compiled. Other approaches may be more appropriate. For example, an
approach that employs land cover as a variable may be more accurate than
some conventional methods, as land cover class is one of the best
indicators of human population density.
The LandScan project, developed at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL),
is a methodology that employs such information. Specifically, global
population at a grid cell size of 1 kilometer is estimated primarily
based on land cover, transportation network proximity, topography
(slope) and high-resolution imagery. LandScan is being refined at ORNL
to yield LandScan USA, a high-resolution database that includes
nighttime/residential and daytime distributions, which is important
given the temporal dimension of potential disasters. LandScan or
LandScan USA population data can be intersected with measured or modeled
disaster maps to determine the threatened population.
In addition, a population database can be used to refine previous
nuclear weapons-based blast casualty rate models. Some previous casualty
rate models were based primarily on data from the Hiroshima and Nagasaki
bombings during World War II. The models were used later to estimate
casualties in U.S. cities following a nuclear attack.
Remote sensing approaches also can be used to assess structural damage
and contamination from various sources. Regardless of whether a disaster
is natural or man-made (e.g., earthquake- or bomb-induced), building
damage assessment is often conducted in situ, especially when interior
structural damage is involved (e.g., the 1993 World Trade Center
bombing). However, radar imaging can be used to image targets through
building walls, thereby aiding post-disaster interior structural damage
assessment and search-and-rescue efforts.
Remote sensing is particularly useful when the
building damage is outwardly apparent. For example, high-resolution pre-
and post-Hurricane Katrina satellite images of New Orleans reveal
hurricane-induced damage to individual structures and flooded areas.
Additionally, close-range remote sensing—in the form of digital video or
in situ spectroradiometer data acquisition—can be used with in situ
mobile GIS data collection, as well as high-resolution airborne or
spaceborne images.
Remotely sensed images for disaster monitoring can be manually/visually
interpreted or analyzed via computer algorithms. For manual photographic
interpretation, large-scale color-infrared (CIR) photography usually is
preferred over other photographic data for various urban
disaster-assessment tasks, including determining the number and type of
buildings damaged, analyzing damage to utilities, and evaluating access
routes to and evacuation routes from a damaged area. Information
extracted from high-resolution optical image data can vary as a function
of image collection time and viewing angle. Shadows, solar illumination
variability and geometric errors can minimize the effectiveness of
automated damage-assessment algorithms, so manual/visual image
interpretation is still one of the most commonly used methods for remote
damage assessment. Automated image analysis/feature-recognition
algorithms often are used to rapidly process a large volume of digital
images.
The type and characteristics of acquired data should be considered for
various urban remote sensing tasks. For emergency scenarios,
pre-disaster images should be acquired every 1 to 5 years, with a
spatial resolution of 1 to 5 meters and spectral coverage in the
panchromatic, visible and near-infrared (NIR). For post-disaster
imagery, panchromatic or NIR high-resolution (≤ 0.25 to 2 meters) data
should be collected as soon as possible. In the event of significant
cloud cover, radar data can provide useful disaster information. For
post-disaster quantitative damage assessments that involve
buildings/housing, transportation and utilities, 0.25- to 1-meter
panchromatic and NIR imagery should be obtained within a couple of days.
Urban areas exhibit high spatial complexity, and
spectral mixing typically occurs across all spatial scales. As a result,
even high-resolution imagery may not lead to accurate urban cover or
damage classifications. In addition, characterizing pre- or
post-disaster urban areas using only pixel-based approaches can be
problematic. For example, per-pixel classifiers can produce structural
clutter—i.e., a salt-and-pepper effect—in the classified image. Given
the high spectral diversity of materials and the high spatial frequency
in urban areas, a region-based approach may compliment spectral-oriented
processing for urban classification.
Change detection-based damage assessment using 2.5-D/3-D building models
also can be conducted, and such models can be constructed via a variety
of methods. For example, airborne laser altimetry and ground plans can
be used to construct a 3-D building model in which a 3-D Hough transform
extracts planar surfaces from the point data clouds. Digital
photogrammetry also can be used to generate urban digital surface
models. Conventional stereo image-matching is used to determine
corresponding pixels in overlapping images, and the resultant surface
model entails elevations based on the visible surfaces of building tops
or vegetation.
Interferometric synthetic aperture radar (IfSAR)
also can be used for building characterization, including identification
and height estimation. IfSAR and hyperspectral data can be combined to
produce urban 3-D surface feature geometry and topography. In addition,
fused SAR and optical data can improve urban damage detection.
Remotely Detecting Non-Radionuclide Contaminants
Radionuclide-based contamination was discussed previously. However,
remote sensing can be applied to other atmospheric plumes/contaminants
from chemical and biological agents.
For example, using a network of pre-positioned biochemical detectors and
locating the point of origin of a chemical or biological weapon release
makes it possible to predict the downwind plume movement with
atmospheric nowcasting, which yields precise information regarding the
current state of the atmosphere over a region. Data can be assimilated
in real time, resulting in frequent updates. Urban-scale numerical
models and detailed knowledge of physics and chemistry enable an
effective operational response.
It’s also possible to use aircraft-based data acquisition for detecting
and monitoring airborne plumes. For example, the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency uses multispectral and hyperspectral passive infrared
sensors to detect and classify absorption and emission features of
chemical vapors. However, detection can be complicated if multiple
chemical or biological agents mix together in the event of a terrorist
attack. Spectral unmixing methods commonly employed in hyperspectral
imaging can be used to classify and estimate the concentration of
chemical and biological agents in a mixture. In addition, LiDAR—particularly
Differential Absorption LiDAR—when used in conjunction with other
sensors, may provide the ability to detect trace chemical
concentrations.
In addition, imaging spectroscopy can be used to evaluate
disaster-associated contaminants. For example, following the 9/11
terrorist attack on the World Trade Center, the U.S. Geological Survey
performed a laboratory reflectance spectroscopy analysis and used
hyperspectral sensor data to assess and map the possible dissemination
of potentially carcinogenic asbestiform dusts.
Remote sensing also can be used to monitor other
contaminants. For example, Hurricane Katrina-induced floodwaters in the
New Orleans area were contaminated with oil and other constituents. SAR
and optical approaches, for instance, have been used to detect and
monitor oil spills for years.
Ongoing Development
Remote sensing enables a wide range of damage-assessment tasks.
Likewise, a broad array of remote sensing technologies can be applied to
a given problem, including photogrammetry, multispectral and
hyperspectral imaging, SAR and LiDAR, among others. Sensors can be
installed on airborne or spaceborne platforms, and in situ networks of
fixed/discrete and dynamic/quasi-ubiquitous sensors play key roles. In
addition, many related technologies and algorithms useful for damage
assessment currently exist and have been proven in real-world scenarios.
Although remote sensing isn’t a damage-assessment panacea, sensor and
information-processing algorithms continue to evolve and improve. As a
result, airborne technology and space-based imagery will be better
situated to respond to a range of current and future threats.